-
Written By Robert Scott
-
Updated on October 14th, 2025
If you’ve tried to attach an MDF file to SQL Server only to receive the error message of “SQL Server Error 5171: MDF is not a primary database file,” you’re not alone. This error indicates that SQL Server was unable to verify the consistency of the database file’s structure.
Summary: This can represent corruption, a deformed file, or something incompatible with SQL Server. It is more than a random bug for database administrators, as it can completely halt an organization’s mission-critical operations. Hence, we discuss key causes, free methods, and an advanced SQL Database Recovery Tool to manage this error. Download Now Purchase Now
When either attaching or restoring the database in SQL Server Management Studio (SSMS), you might encounter an error message:
“The file is not a primary database file. (Microsoft SQL Server, Error: 5171)”
This means SQL Server could not validate or verify the file as a valid MDF (primary data) file. The file header or meta-information is unreadable, or it does not fit an expected structure.
|
Note: MDF files store data as pages, and the size of each page is 8 KB. The first one is the header page with all the crucial details like size, signature, compatibility, etc. |
This error can pop up due to any of the reasons mentioned below:
After understanding the reasons, let’s learn what actually happens when this error arises. It states how exactly the professionals and other users were troubled due to this error:
There are a few manual troubleshooting methods that you can try to fix this error code 5171. On the other hand, a professional tool prevails, which immediately fixes the error and MDF file corruption, providing you with database access and direct saving. To understand the methods briefly, follow the step-by-step guide below.
If there is minimal corruption or a misplaced file, SQL Server’s built-in tools will work as follows:
1) Check the Type of File
Ensure attaching an actual MDF file and not an LDF or NDF file. If you really need to, use SQL Server’s command line to check the file headers.
2) Create a New Database & Replace the MDF
The steps to do so are:
|
EXEC sp_attach_single_file_db @databasename=’DbName’, @physname=’C:\Path\YourDB.mdf’ |
3) Fix Mirrored Databases
For mirrored databases, you need to use the command “ALTER DATABASE mydatabase SET online” to work. But if the error 5171 occurs instead, then follow these steps:


4) Restoration From Backup
If you can, restoring from the latest clean backup is usually the best choice if your database is damaged in any way. Use the command:
|
RESTORE DATABASE DBName FROM DISK = ‘C:\Backup\DBName.bak’ WITH REPLACE; |
If you don’t have a recent backup, begin with a dedicated recovery tool. This is also because, though the above troubleshooting solutions work, they are not suited for everyone and may not give appropriate results in more critical cases.
When regular fixes may not work, most users prefer a trusted and verified SQL Database Recovery Tool. It is designed to repair internal corruption, rebuild MDF headers, and recover inaccessible objects (tables, triggers, and stored procedures from the database). Additionally, it:
Quick Steps to Fix SQL Server Database Error 5171






SQL Server Error 5171 is a critical warning that your MDF file cannot be recognized as a valid primary database file, or is often a major sign of corruption or version mismatch. The manual options for recovery of corrupt databases with minor issues are feasible. However, recovering severely corrupted databases often requires strong, professional-grade recovery options. For business enterprises, especially, ensuring you can get to your data whenever called upon is paramount. Hence, using the recovery tool is ideal to ensure everything follows correctly.
Ans. Microsoft SQL Error 5171 occurs when SQL Server cannot recognize an MDF file as a valid primary database file due to corruption, the wrong type of file, or a version mismatch.
Ans. The SysInfo SQL Database Recovery Software is the most reliable solution. It will repair the MDF and NDF file(s), restore tables, stored procedures, and other objects that reside in the database while maintaining the integrity of the original database schema.
Ans. This depends on the size and severity of the corruption of the database. In smaller databases up to 1 GB, this can sometimes take a few minutes. In several larger enterprise database cases, it could be longer, depending on the length to recover data, the number of transactions in the database, and the capabilities of the recovery hardware. To ensure it is done in minimal time, get the SQL Repair Software!
About The Author:
With more than five years of experience in email migration, Data Recovery, Email Backup, and File Management, I combine my years of experience with a strong interest in new technology. My professional journey is fueled by a genuine passion for navigating and mastering the latest advancements in these fields, ensuring that I stay ahead of the curve and bring innovative solutions to the table.
Related Post